On the first night, the living room was a cinema. Velvet throw blankets became curtains, laptops lined the coffee table like lanterns, and a projector threw an old, grainy print across plaster. We arrived in stages: the ones who loved scoring dialogue with delighted whoops, the quiet types whose reactions came later, braided through a grin. Someone had brewed coffee for the long haul. Someone else had compiled a list — not top-grossing, not awards-heavy, simply the films that left them restless afterward. These were the candidates for "best."